Results tagged ‘ Bartolo Colon ’
Through five innings Saturday, Phil Hughes had thrown 86 pitches. I thought here’s another situation in which the righthander cannot moderate his pitch count and that Yankees manager Joe Girardi would have to get his bullpen in gear early.
But lo and behold, Hughes got more efficient with his pitches and came up with three straight 1-2-3 innings to be in good position to get his first winning decision of the season. Phil certainly earned it with eight shutout innings in which he allowed four hits and two walks with a season-high nine strikeouts.
Things got a bit hairy in the ninth when Shawn Kelley gave up a leadoff single, and Girardi did not hesitate to call on Mariano Rivera in a non-save situation. Mo gave up a walk and a hit with a couple of runs scoring, but the 4-2 Yankees final gave Hughes that long-awaited first victory of the season.
“I knew my pitch count was pretty high the first five innings,” Hughes said. “It all starts with the fastball. I got more aggressive with it on both sides of the plate and then I could mix in off-speed stuff.”
Hughes’ 117-pitch effort included an unusually high number of strikes – 82 – and marked his fourth consecutive outing of six or more innings in which he allowed two or fewer runs. He has held opponents to a .223 batting average in that stretch. Over those starts, Hughes had brought his ERA down from 10.29 to 3.60. “I feel like I’m clicking now,” he said.
For the second straight outing at Yankee Stadium, Hughes kept the ball in the yard, something he had not done before his previous start since last August. The long ball will always be a nemesis for Hughes, a fly-ball pitcher (10 of his 24 outs Saturday were in the air), but it is worth noting that all five homers he has allowed this year have come with the bases empty.
Ichiro Suzuki saved Hughes from yielding a home run to the first batter of the game, catcher John Jaso, with a fence-climbing catch in right field. A couple of other drives reached the warning track but stayed out of the stands.
“The consistency of his pitches every inning” was Girardi’s explanation for the turnaround in Hughes since his first two poor starts to open the season. “He mixed in all his stuff the second and third time through the order.”
Hughes’ offensive support came mainly from the bottom of the order – home runs from 9-hole hitter Chris Stewart in the third and 7-hole hitter Lyle Overbay in the fifth off Athletics starter Bartolo Colon and a triple by 8-hole hitter Eduardo Nunez, who scored on a two-out single by Brett Gardner in the seventh. The other run came from cleanup hitter Travis Hafner with a single in the sixth that scored Robinson Cano, who had doubled to lead off the inning against Colon.
That double was career No. 344 for Cano, who broke a tie with Hall of Famers Bill Dickey and Mickey Mantle to take over eighth place on the franchise’s all-time list.
Colon, who was 8-10 for the Yankees in 2011, lost for the first time in four decisions this year despite another good outing (three runs, six hits, no walks, three strikeouts in 5 1/3 innings). A control freak of a power pitcher, Colon has tossed 37 1/3 innings in 2013 and walked one batter.
The Yankees are 28-9 in games immediately following shutout losses since the start of the 2008 season (all under Girardi) with victories in both cases this year and 11 of the past 13. . .Hughes, with a 1.93 ERA and 30 strikeouts over his past four starts covering 28 innings, became the first right-handed starter for the Yankees to pitch at least eight shutout innings and strike out at least nine batters in a game since Mike Mussina Sept. 14, 2004 at Kansas City and the first to do so at the Stadium since Roger Clemens June 18, 2003 against the Rays. . .Hafner has at least one RBI in nine of the Yankees’ 10 series this season. . .Stewart entered 2013 with four homers in 351 career at-bats. He has two in 40 at-bats this season. . .Rivera’s 1,064th career appearance tied him with Dan Plesac for sixth place on the all-time games list. . .The Yankees are 17-2 when holding opponents to four or fewer runs and 16-3 when scoring four or more runs.
Friday night’s loss to the Mets at Citi Field ended the Yankees’ road winning streak at seven, their longest such stretch since they won eight in a row June 24-July 9, 2009. The five runs they allowed in the first inning was the most they have allowed in the opening inning of a game since July 14 last year when the Blue Jays scored eight runs (three earned) off Bartolo Colon in a 16-7 Toronto victory.
The Elias Sports Bureau reported that the Yankees became the last team in the majors to allow more than four runs in any inning this season. It was only the third time in Andy Pettitte’s 487 regular-season starts that he allowed at least five runs in the first inning. The other times were Sept. 4, 2001 at Toronto – five runs – and Aug. 21, 1995 at Oakland – six runs.
Clay Rapada’s impressive stretch of 21 consecutive batters held hitless was ended in the eighth inning when Mets second baseman Justin Turner doubled. Rapada has set down each of the past 16 left-handed batters he has faced and has limited lefty swingers to a .137 batting average in 51 at-bats for the season with just two extra-base hits, one double and one home run.
The Yankees’ 27 errors this season are the fewest in the majors. They also lead the majors with a .989 fielding percentage. In Joe Girardi’s term as manager since 2008, the Yankees have combined for a .986 fielding percentage, the best in the American League and second in the majors only to the Phillies’ .989.
Ivan Nova entered Saturday night’s start with a 12-game winning streak on the road. The club record for consecutive road victories is 15. It was set over the 1936 and ’37 seasons by Monte Pearson and tied over the 1948 and ’49 seasons by Allie Reynolds. Russ Ford of the old New York Highlanders won 13 straight road decisions over the 1910 and ’11 seasons.
Rays fans cheered Rafael Soriano throughout the 2010 season as he registered a league-leading 45 saves for Tampa Bay that earned him a multi-year, mega-bucks contract as a free agent with the Yankees. He was the object of a joyful Tropicana Field audience Tuesday night when Soriano gave up a three-run home run to Matt Joyce in the seventh inning that sent the Rays toward a 5-3 victory that kept alive their hopes for a wild-card playoff berth.
Three was the key number for the Rays in this one. Joyce’s three-run bomb followed by one inning a triple play pulled off by the Tampa Bay infield that snuffed out a Yankees rally that threatened to break the game open. The Yanks had taken a 3-2 lead on a walk and doubles by Mark Teixeira and Nick Swisher.
An intentional walk to Jorge Posada loaded the bases for Russell Martin, who had homered off Rays rookie Jeremy Hellickson earlier in the game. Martin hit a hard grounder to third base where Evan Longoria gloved it, stepped on the bag and instead of throwing home for the lead runner shot the ball to second base where Ben Zobrist relayed to first for the triple killing. That was a tremendously heady play by Longoria, who realized the guy who hit the ball was a catcher and gave the triple play attempt a try.
The play seemed to revive the Rays, who were able to score only two runs in 5 1/3 innings off a so-so Bartolo Colon, who remained winless in 10 starts since July 30 (0-4, 5.37 ERA). After the game, Yankees manager Joe Girardi spoke of Colon’s contributions this season in the past tense, which seemed to indicate that the veteran righthander might not be on the staff for the first round of the playoffs.
The Yankees are still trying to decide what to do to prepare for the Division Series because they do not yet know who they will play, either Detroit or Texas. As for the wild card, that will go down to the last game. The Red Sox hung on for an 8-7 victory in Baltimore. David Price will start for Tampa Bay Wednesday night against a collection of Yankees pitchers who will not be on the postseason roster.
Girardi warned the Red Sox this was going to happen. With the American League East and home-field advantage for the first two rounds in place, the Yankees don’t owe Boston anything.
The Yankees’ 5-2 loss at Tropicana Field Monday night means that they cannot win 100 games this year. They needed to sweep the Rays in the season-ending, three-game set to get into three figures in victories for the 20th time in franchise history.
It is no big deal because the Yankees have done everything they wanted to do, which was to win the American League East and finish with the best record in the league that will give them home field advantage in the Division Series and League Championship Series. Reaching 100 in the W column would have been a nice topping on the season but one that was not necessary.
Not that Yankees fans ever like to see them lose, but falling to Tampa Bay combined with the Red Sox’ loss at Baltimore means the Rays have pulled into a tie for the wild card berth with Boston, which has squandered a nine-game lead in those standings since Sept. 4. If the teams should remain tied after Tuesday night’s game, there could be pressure on Yankees manager Joe Girardi to field a representative lineup for the last game of the season if the wild-card slot is still on the line.
Girardi made it clear before the Yankees left for St. Petersburg, Fla., that he was starting Bartolo Colon Tuesday night and that Wednesday night’s finale would be handled by the bullpen. He has no reason to do anything differently. Girardi’s first responsibility is to the Yankees. He used a lot of regulars last weekend against the Red Sox and last week and Monday night against the Rays. He is under no obligation for the integrity of the game to do something that might hurt his team’s chances in postseason play, which begins Friday night.
The Red Sox and the Rays had a 162-game schedule and 18 games apiece against the Yankees to stay close to them. Boston in particular has no gripe. The Red Sox got into this fix by themselves and should not expect any kind of helping hand from the Yankees now.
While they have clarified their postseason situation by clinching the American League East title and guaranteeing home field advance in the Division Series and League Championship Series, the Yankees nonetheless find themselves in the middle of a race for a playoff berth.
The wild card slot is still up for grabs among two of their AL East competitors, the Red Sox and Rays, and the long-shot Angels of the AL West. The Yankees continued Boston’s September slide with a 6-2 victory in the afternoon portion of the split-bill doubleheader Sunday at Yankee Stadium. The Rays won at home against the Blue Jays to move to a half-game behind the Red Sox in the wild-card standings.
Had the Red Sox lost the night game Sunday, the nine-game lead they held over Tampa Bay Sept. 4 would have completely evaporated. The Red Sox may have saved their season by overcoming a 3-0, first-inning deficit and winning, 7-4, in 14 innings on Jacoby Ellsbury’s third home run of the day to retain their one-game lead for the wild card.
It doesn’t get any easier for the Rays because they have to play the Yankees in their final three games at Tropicana Field while the Red Sox finish up at Baltimore. So the Yankees are still involved in this mix. In the meantime, they are getting a lot of positive vibes about their pitching as they prepare for the postseason. After Freddy Garcia pitched six shutout innings Saturday, A.J. Burnett turned in his best performance in more than two months in the Sunday matinee.
The Stadium crowd of 49,541 bestowed a standing ovation on Burnett as he left the mound with two out in the eighth inning after limiting the Red Sox to two runs and five hits – two of them home runs by Ellsbury, who had three of the hits off the righthander. Burnett walked two batters and struck out six and for a nice change of pace he did not hit a batter, throw a wild pitch or allow a stolen base.
This was an A.J. Burnett start out of 2009, his first season in pinstripes when he was 13-9. His curve was a huge weapon Sunday as Burnett got his record back to .500 at 11-11. It was only his third victory in 15 starts since June 29 but his second straight winning decision. The timing could not be better.
CC Sabathia, who threw a simulated game Sunday and declared himself ready to go, will start Game 1 of the ALDS Friday night at the Stadium against an opponent yet unknown. Yankees manager Joe Girardi has yet to reveal his postseason rotation but Sabathia in Game 1 is a given.
It is also expected that Ivan Nova, Sunday night’s starter who pitched 6 1/3 innings and got a no-decision, will get the ball in Game 2, although that is not a certainty. Burnett and Garcia are in a competition for the other postseason starting assignments with Bartolo Colon and Phil Hughes, who will make their cases in the Tampa Bay series.
The Yankees solved Tim Wakefield’s knuckleball Sunday behind veterans Derek Jeter and Jorge Posada. Brett Gardner and Jeter, who bunted for hits in the first inning, each scored without a hit. Gardner came home on an error by catcher Jarrod Saltalamacchia and Jeter on a wild pitch to put the Red Sox in an early, 2-0 hole.
Posada, batting cleanup for the first time since 2009, hit his fourth career homer off Wakefield, a two-run shot in the third. The crowd ate it up, and Jorgie responded with a curtain call. What a far cry from that May 14 Yanks-Red Sox game when Posada objected to batting ninth and asked out of the lineup. Talk about ancient history.
Jeter added two more hits, a single and a double, that brought his batting average to .300 for the first time since after the second game of the season when he was at .333 on 2-for-6. Jeter was batting .260 when he came off the disabled list July 4. He has hit .338 since then. As late as Aug. 10, the Captain was hitting .271. Over his past 37 games, he has batted .372. DJ got to .299 twice late last month but dipped as low as .292 Sept. 17. Jeter’s current hot streak covers six games in which he has 11-for-22 (.500) with 2 doubles, 1 home run and 4 RBI.
The Yankees’ clinching gives Girardi a chance to rest regulars and give youngsters a chance to get some major-league experience. Perhaps the most pleasant aspect in that regard Sunday was the defensive work at first base by Brandon Laird, who made several sparking plays.
In the nightcap, the Yankees got outstanding relief work until Scott Proctor came on in the 14th and gave up a hit and a walk before Ellsbury connected. Unfortunately, the Red Sox bullpen had an even better night as they held the Yankees to one hit over eight shutout innings.
It was another extra-inning loss for the Yankees, who are 4-11 when going past the ninth, the worst record in the league and the third worst in franchise history, trailing only the 1-9 record of 1933 and the 3-9 of 1949.
The Yankees finished the home season with a 52-29 mark, tied with the Rangers for the best in the AL. The regular-season attendance of 3,653,380 and average of 45,107 per game led the AL, which marked the ninth consecutive season that the Yankees have drawn the most fans at home. This year’s 20 sellouts were the most in the three-year history of the current Stadium.
What a terrific game to be the one in which Mariano Rivera tied the career record for saves. After four innings, it would have been hard to predict that Mo would even get into the game because the Yankees appeared buried as they trailed, 6-1, behind a shaky Bartolo Colon, who was scorched for six earned runs and seven hits.
Considering the state of the Yankees’ offense on this trip, a comeback seemed unlikely. The Yankees entered Saturday’s game at Toronto batting .200 in 265 at-bats and averaging 3.5 runs per game on the trip in which they had lost five of eight games. But after the roaring comeback sparked by the power of Alex Rodriguez and Curtis Granderson and supplemented by the hitless work of five relievers, the Yankees have a chance to play .500 on a ragged trip that ends Sunday.
Rivera’s wife Clara and sons Mariano Jr., Jafet and Jaziel were in the crowd of 39,288 at Rogers Centre cheering him on as he bore down for his 42nd save of the season with a 1-2-3 ninth that brought his career total to 601, tying him with Trevor Hoffman for the all-time record. One more save, perhaps Sunday or even better when the team returns to Yankee Stadium Monday, and Mo will have no rivals as baseball’s saves master.
Rivera is already acknowledged as the game’s greatest closer. That saves total does not include the 42 he has recorded in postseason play, which is at the core of his legacy. Watching him after the last out as he walked off the mound and toward the center fielder, Granderson, who put away the 27th out and hit a home run that gave the Yankees the lead, gave one a glance at a professional in action, the game’s classiest act.
Later in talking to reporters, Rivera spoke more about the comeback his teammates staged that put him in position to get the save. To Mo, the most important thing about notching a save is that it means his team has won the game.
I had pointed out Friday night that the Yankees, who have had four walk-off losses on the trip, needed to reverse the trend of one-run losses. Saturday’s 7-6 victory was a start. They are now 21-23 in one-run games, including 9-14 on the road. In addition, they kept up their dominance in day games with a 40-11 mark.
Rodriguez was back in the lineup after eight games on the shelf nursing a sprained left thumb. He was not in his familiar cleanup spot but in the 5-hole, the first time he has batted there in five years. Yankees manager Joe Girardi kept Robinson Cano in the cleanup spot where he has done superbly in A-Rod’s absence, although the All-Star second baseman had a strange day Saturday.
The Yankees needed a good dose of Alex, and he did not disappoint. Batting with a split-hand grip with tape on the bat between his hands to protect the thumb, Rodriguez lashed a single his first time up. He hit the ball hard again in his second at-bat but grounded out. Then in the fifth, he bashed the first pitch from Henderson Alvarez over the left field wall for his 16th home run, a three-run shot that got the Yankees to 6-5.
The Yankees were now in a game in which they had botched earlier chances to score. Cano made his second base-running blunder of the trip by passing Mark Teixeira at third base that resulted in a rally-killing double play after a sensational catch on the center field track by Colby Rasmus of a drive by Nick Swisher. The Yankees settled for one run that inning on a Cano sacrifice fly but failed to take advantage of an error by left fielder Adam Loewen that seemed to have opened the door for them. The next inning, Brett Gardner tripled with one down but was stranded.
Granderson, who had a perfect day (3-for-3, 2 walks, 2 RBI, 3 runs) jump-started the Yanks in the sixth with a leadoff double. Curtis has had a rough September, batting .189 this month and .133 on the trip entering play Saturday watching his average drop to .264 and his Most Valuable Player aspirations sink as well.
Perhaps Granderson started turning things around with this game. He scored on a throwing error by Rasmus off a single by Teixeira. Alvarez was coming apart at this point. He hit Cano with a pitch before serving up a first-pitch fastball to A-Rod, who scalded it for his 629th career homer, one behind fifth-place Ken Griffey Jr. on the all-time list.
Carlos Villanueva took over in the seventh, and the Yankees didn’t waste any time jumping on him. Derek Jeter beat out an infield hit on one of four ground balls he hit to shortstop in the game and scored on Granderson’s 40th home run, an impressive blow that cleared the center field wall.
While the Yankees were making all this noise, their bullpen kept the Blue Jays quiet. Colon, who remained winless in eight starts since July 30 and is 0-3 with a 4.98 during that stretch, was gone after four innings. Scott Proctor, Adam Laffey, Hector Noesi, Rafael Soriano and Rivera pitched one inning of hitless relief apiece. Soriano struck out the side in the eighth for the second straight game (he did the same Friday night in the seventh inning).
For Rivera, this was a save to be savored.
Maybe the bright side for the Yankees Friday night is that they did not have to play extra innings for the third day in a row, even though going extras was their only shot at pulling out a victory after they were retired in the ninth with the score 1-1.
There were actual bright sides for the Yankees in the 2-1 loss to the Angels, but not many. The Yankees got to play in ideal weather conditions for a change in the blissful climate of Anaheim, Calif., after two long games on wet tracks in the Bronx and Baltimore.
The Elias Sports Bureau pointed out that the Yankees’ back-to-back losses to the Orioles at Yankee Stadium Wednesday night and at Camden Yards Thursday marked the second time in major-league history that a team lost in extra innings on consecutive days to the same team in different ballparks. It also occurred April 19 and 20, 1900 when the Boston Beaneaters (now the Atlanta Braves) lost to the Philadelphia Phillies, 19-17, in 10 innings at the South End Grounds in Boston and at Philadelphia’s Baker Bowl the next day, 5-4, in 11 innings.
The recent toll on the bullpen left the Yankees vulnerable as manager Joe Girardi trusted the ninth inning to Aaron Laffey and Luis Ayala. The Angels loaded the bases against them on two singles and a hit batter with none out, which allowed pinch hitter Maicer Izturis to win the game with a sacrifice fly to medium center field. Curtis Granderson didn’t even attempt a throw to combat speedy pinch runner Jeremy Moore. Curtis should have thrown home anyway. You never know; Moore might have tripped or fallen down.
Granderson’s career-high 11 assists are the most by a Yankees center fielder since 2007 when Melky Cabrera had 14. Granderson had two assists Thursday, the first Yankees center fielder to do that since Omar Moreno in 1984
The Yankees’ failure to generate any kind of offense against American League Cy Young Award candidate Jered Weaver wasted a strong pitching performance by Bartolo Colon, who remained winless in seven starts since July 30. Colon is 0-3 with four no-decisions and a 4.19 ERA during this stretch, but he was flawless Friday night allowing six hits and a walk with five strikeouts in seven innings. The only run he allowed was not earned due to a throwing error by Derek Jeter.
The shortstop’s wild throw in the fifth that proved costly when Howie Kendrick got a two-out, RBI single marked the sixth straight game in which the Yankees have committed an error. The Yankees have 11 errors in nine games in September, one more than they had in all of August (28 games).
Jesus Montero continued his sizzling September (.350 in 20 at-bats) with a long home run to left field off Weaver leading off the third inning. It was the third home run for Montero, all of which have come off right-handed pitchers. Girardi started Montero as the designated hitter against a righthander for the first time. Expect that to happen on a regular basis.
Andruw Jones, who usually is the DH against righties, played right field because Nick Swisher is down with a painful left elbow. The switch-hitter is a left-handed thrower, so the situation bears very close watching.
Montero was the only Yankees batter to get past first base against Weaver, who gave up two other hits, both singles, and two walks while striking out 11 in eight innings. He was stuck with a tough no-decision as well. The victory went to rookie closer Jordan Walden, who pitched the ninth. He walked Alex Rodriguez with one out, but the Angels guessed right on a pitchout and catcher Jeff Mathis nailed pinch runner Eduardo Nunez trying to steal second base.
The Yankees’ three-game losing streak is simultaneous with that of Boston, so their lead in the AL East remains 2 ½ games over the Red Sox, which counts as a bright spot.
There seemed to have been a fade in the effectiveness of Bartolo Colon once the dog days of August arrived. There was a time when August was Colon’s month. Prior to this season, he was 27-11 in the month and still had the fourth highest winning percentage in August of any active pitcher heading into Tuesday night’s game.
Perhaps it was inevitable that things would change this year. After all, Colon is 38 years old and pitching with a surgically-repaired right shoulder that after a year of relative inactivity has logged more than 130 innings. He didn’t win again Tuesday night, but he pitched better than the numbers would indicate (6 1/3 innings, 8 hits, 5 earned runs, 5 strikeouts, 2 home runs).
What was so good about all that? Well, both home runs were solos because he did not walk a batter, which is always a plus, and two of the runs scored after he left the game in the seventh as Boone Logan gave up a double to pinch hitter Scott Sizemore. That does not absolve Colon, who still must prove he belongs in the rotation once the Yankees get to September.
He was rolling along there for a while and looking very much like the Yankees’ No. 2 starter behind American League Cy Young Award candidate CC Sabathia. But in his four starts since his last victory July 30, Colon is 0-2 with a 5.73 ERA in 22 innings in which he has allowed 26 hits, including six home runs.
I have felt for a while that the Yankees might have been better served with Colon pitching out of the bullpen to keep his innings from getting out of hand and to have him throw as hard as he can (which can get up to 97 mph) over short doses. Colon stepped up big time, however, when Phil Hughes stumbled out of the gate and had to go on the disabled list with arm fatigue.
When Hughes returned two months later, Colon was a stalwart in the rotation, and the Yankees chose to option Ivan Nova to Triple A Scranton/Wilkes-Barre. After a month away, Nova has come back to pitch himself into the AL Jackie Robinson Rookie of the Year conversation, so the rotation has gotten mighty crowded.
The Yankees will stay in a six-man rotation through Saturday’s dual-admission doubleheader at Camden Yards. After that, Yankees manager Joe Girardi has a decision to make in slicing his rotation down to five. My vote would be to use Colon out of the pen. It would not be a demotion in any way.
Considering the recent troubles of A.J. Burnett, a good long man in the pen is a priority. Colon was willing to work as a reliever when he signed with the Yankees. He is happy enough to be back in the major leagues that I believe he would accept this assignment willingly and would greatly improve the makeup of the staff.
Was that Brandon Allen who hit a home run in the third deck of right field at Yankee Stadium in the second inning Tuesday night, or Dick Allen?
Not too many balls have reached that level of the new Stadium since its opening in 2009. Mark Teixeira drove one up there last year, and regular Stadium basher Russell Branyan also parked one in that section. Brandon Allen joined the group with his blast off Bartolo Colon.
Dick Allen, who was both a Rookie of the Year (National League, 1964, with the Phillies) and a Most Valuable Player (American League, 1972, with the White Sox) was a masher of the first order in the 1960s and ‘70s. He hit 351 home runs, several of them in orbit. Dick Allen was a right-handed batter, however, so the chances of his hitting one into the upper deck in right field at the Stadium was pretty remote.
I recall that back in his era Allen was a player mentioned about having a chance to hit a fair ball out of the old Stadium along with Mickey Mantle, Harmon Killebrew and Frank Howard. No one ever did it.
Brandon Allen, a left-handed batter, came to Oakland on the July 31 trading deadline from Arizona in a deal for pitcher Brad Ziegler. Allen began the year in the minors and hit .172 in 11 games for the Diamondbacks before the trade. He entered Tuesday night’s game batting .379 in nine games, but this was his first home run for the A’s and fourth of the year and long enough to count for two.
What good is giving the umpires access to a video replay to make calls on questionable home runs if they get it wrong anyway? That clearly was the case Wednesday night at Kansas City’s Kauffman Stadium that cost Bartolo Colon and the Yankees a run in the third inning.
At issue was a drive to left-center by Royals designated hitter Billy Butler that was called a home run. Yankees manager Joe Girardi immediately argued the call and persuaded second base umpire Dana DeMuth to review the play, which Major League Baseball put into effect two years ago.
Left fielder Brett Gardner retrieved the ball and seeing DeMuth signaling home run merely tossed it back to the infield. Butler kept running around the bases, but the Yankees were sure he would be told to go no farther than second base upon review of the play by the umps.
Various replays showed that the ball hit a barrier at the top of the wall and caromed back onto the field. It was as clear as could be that the ball did not go over the barrier, which the grounds rules call for to make it a home run. Yet four sets of eyes reviewing the play upheld the original call. What was funny was to watch Butler in the Kansas City dugout as he first reached for his helmet perhaps thinking he would have to return to the field and then making a sheepish grin to teammates as he put the helmet back into the rack.
How about the reaction of Mariano Rivera? Baseball’s model of cool and collected behavior for years, Rivera was livid in the dugout about the umpires’ decision. At one point, he got into a shouting match with plate umprire Chad Fairchild and had to be restrained by Girardi to avoid being thrown out of a game he might have been called on later to save.
For that to happen, however, the Yankees would have had to regain the lead that Colon lost. Butler’s home run was the second of the third inning off Colon. The other, a three-run shot by Alex Gordon, was more damaging because it wiped out a 2-0 deficit. Curtis Granderson got the Yankees started in the first inning with his 34th home run and also scored the second run in the third when he doubled and came home on a two-out single by Nick Swisher.
Colon seemed a bit out of sorts with too many pitches staying up in the zone and was outpitched by journeyman lefthander Bruce Chen, who is pitching for his 10th major-league club and entered the game with a career record against the Yankees of 1-5 with a 6.71 ERA. Colon was gone after five innings after allowing five earned runs and seven hits in 99 pitches. With a six-man rotation still in place while Freddy Garcia recovers from a finger injury, the Yankees may have to consider Colon as a possible candidate to go to the bullpen.
As for that Butler home run, it turned out to be the difference maker in a 5-4 Royals victory. The Yankees cut the margin to one with a run in the ninth off shaky closer Joakim Soria. The run was scored by Derek Jeter, who was 4-for-5 and is now batting .290, on a sacrifice fly by Robinson Cano.
The Yanks had the bases loaded with two out and birthday boy Jorge Posada, who turned 40, at the plate. A hit there would have been than a birthday cake for Jorgie, but he was called out on strikes, a tough way to end a birthday.